AC47321 - Ringel v. Gottlieb ("In this property dispute, the plaintiffs, Gerald Ringel and Wanda Ringel, appeal from the judgment of the trial court, rendered after a bench trial, in favor of the defendant, Maria Genedina Gottlieb. On appeal, the plaintiffs claim that the court erred by (1) holding that the warranty deed at issue clearly and unambiguously reserved a general beach easement for the defendant's use of the plaintiffs' property above the mean high water line and (2) making findings and issuing orders pertaining to claims that the defendant had withdrawn prior to trial. We agree and, accordingly, reverse the judgment of the trial court.")