- SC20666 - High Watch Recovery Center, Inc. v. Dept. of Public Health (Contested hearing; subject matter jurisdiction "Held that the Appellate Court incorrectly concluded that the plaintiff’s petition requesting intervenor status in the public hearing on B Co.’s certificate of need application was not a legally sufficient request for a public
hearing for purposes of § 19a-639a (e), and, accordingly, the department’s decision to approve B Co.’s application was a final decision in
a contested case:
Contrary to the defendants’ contention that, to satisfy § 19a-639a (e),
the plaintiff was required to expressly state in its petition to intervene
that it was an entity with five or more people, that statute does not
impose such a requirement but merely provides that an entity must be
an entity with five or more people to be entitled to a hearing, and it was
undisputed that the plaintiff satisfied that numerical requirement and
that the OHCA was fully aware of that fact.
Furthermore, given the undisputed fact that the OHCA had already scheduled a public hearing on B Co.’s application, this court discerned no
ambiguity with respect to the plaintiff’s request because, when the OHCA
has already scheduled a public hearing, it is only logical that a party
wanting to oppose the application would request intervenor status in
that hearing, not request another or a different hearing, and that was
precisely what the public notice instructed the plaintiff to do if it wanted
to be heard on the plaintiff’s application.")